Your 401(k) Employer Match: Should You Pay Taxes Now or in Retirement?
What Should You Ask Your Employer?
Shanti
11/16/20262 min read
Your 401(k) Employer Match: Should You Pay Taxes Now or in Retirement?
Suppose the company you work for adds $1,000 to your retirement account this year because you contributed some of your own pay. That extra money is called an employer match. Some companies now let you choose when to pay income tax on it. You can pay the tax this year or wait until you withdraw the money in retirement.
According to CNBC, more employers in the United States are offering this choice. In a survey by the Plan Sponsor Council of America, 42.4% of participating employers said they already offered a Roth option for employer contributions or planned to add one. A year earlier, that figure was 19.7%.
A $1,000 Example
If your employer puts the $1,000 into the traditional portion of your 401(k), it does not count toward your taxable income this year. The money is invested in your account. When you withdraw it in retirement, you pay income tax on the amount you take out, including any investment earnings.
If you choose Roth, the full $1,000 still goes into your retirement account, but it also counts toward your taxable income for the year. Suppose your federal tax rate on that additional income is 22%. The match would add about $220 to your federal tax bill this year. Later, if you meet the requirements for a qualified withdrawal, you can withdraw both the original $1,000 and its investment earnings without paying income tax on either.
Which Option Makes Sense for You?
Consider the tax rate you pay today and the rate you expect to pay when you withdraw the money. For example, if your income is lower this year because you are in school or working part time, and you expect your tax rate to be higher in retirement, choosing Roth could save you money. If you are in your peak earning years and expect to pay a lower tax rate in retirement, the traditional option may make more sense.
Your budget matters, too. In the example above, choosing Roth means making room for an additional $220 in federal income tax this year.
What Should You Ask Your Employer?
Even if your own contributions go into a Roth 401(k), your employer’s match may still go into the traditional portion of your account. You can ask your benefits team, “Where does the company match go today? Can I choose Roth for the match separately from my own contributions?”
If you choose Roth, keep one detail in mind. Federal income tax is not automatically withheld from the employer match when it goes into your account. The amount is reported on Form 1099‑R. Your paycheck may look the same, but when you file your tax return, you could receive a smaller refund or owe more tax.
Contact Us
Reach out anytime for personalized support
Phone
Lionyx Insurance · 22503 Katy Fwy Ste 43, Katy, TX 77450 · © 2026. All rights reserved.
